"Good bad taste is celebrating something without thinking you’re
better than it. You think it’s so amazing, and you could have never even
thought it up.
"Bad bad taste is condescending, making fun of others.
"So that’s the difference for me: if you’re celebrating something or you’re looking down on something."
If you've ever seen any video of a live act, you know: You MUST be in
the room to really get the full effect. A video may sometimes look
pretty, but more often than not it looks horrible. It is impossible to
get an accurate video artifact of a live performance unless you're a
Martin Scorsese or Jonathan Demme, and even then the level of trickery
and control employed is well beyond the means of your average
videographer, no matter how dedicated or awesome that videographer may
be.
To say something is "lost in translation" when a video or (god help you) photo of an act is chanced upon online is to engage in superlative understatement. You can't judge a book by its cover, and you most certainly can't judge a burlesque act by its fat suit.
Brandy Snifter's Divine act is a loving tribute to
everything that Divine and the films of John Waters have come to
symbolize. Embracing the outsider, reveling in what "decent" society considers trash.
Brandy doesn't do glib, dilettante work when she takes the stage. She is fully committed to everything she does onstage. She's not playing
at Divine, she's
playing Divine. Her Divine drag is perfect. She looks like Divine, and she fully owns the persona. Everything is on point, including the overall silhouette.
She's not shaming fat people for being overweight. To say that would be to say she's shaming Divine for being overweight, and of course that is not what Brandy is doing.
And herein lies the controversy. Brandy performs a striptease, down to a "fat suit." On its face, it sounds bad. Still photos and video taken out of context may seem shocking. In context of the act, dismissively calling it a "fat suit" is a pejorative. When Brandy strips down to and out of the fat suit, she's not shedding layers of fat; she's shedding a specific silhouette. She's shedding Divine' s silhouette. She's not shaming fat people for being overweight. To say that would be to say she's shaming Divine for being overweight, and
of course that is not what Brandy is doing.
Of course it's not.
Brandy is not propping up a caricature as a representation of reality in order to belittle others. Her act is not a metamorphosis of a fat person becoming skinny. In fact-- and this is some deep shit here -- Brandy is revealing something very personal about how she views herself by taking on the mantle of Divine. Brandy is stripping away the externals of Divine to get to the core of Brandy Snifter, as if to say, "This is who I am."
Brandy Snifter's reveal is not a "fat suit." Her reveal is something deeply personal about herself.
It's easy to get tripped up on the external, and that's rather the problem. Getting tripped up on the external is what the "straights" do to the heroes in John Waters movies. Tripping out on the fact that Brandy Snifter strips down to a fat suit is like tripping out that Glenn Milstead didn't really have tits. It misses the point by a mile while simultaneously proving the greater point. It proves the necessity of this kind of an act.
Brandy Snifter's reveal is not a "fat suit." Her reveal is something deeply personal about herself.
Somehow we've gone through a wormhole where we have to remind people that it's okay to be weird and different. We're all weird and different now, all of us, all weird and different just exactly the same as all the other weird and different people. When a person stands up and presents something personal and genuinely outre, what do we do? The same thing society has done to the outre since the beginning of society. Shun. Ostracize. Make them feel lesser-than.
That is the great tragedy in all of the hoopla that has surrounded Brandy's act. The reaction to it, the outrage and subsequent belittling of a performer who is honestly putting herself out there, is exactly the sort of thing that would piss off a person like Divine.
If you are an injured party in all this and feel you have some legitimate claim to feeling offended, that's your prerogative. You are absolutely entitled to your opinions and feelings, and no one can say boo about that. But I would ask that before you go on a wrecking campaign against another person's reputation, at least try to understand where they're coming from.
You may not like the art, but you might just come to respect the artist.